Viewfinder 2 - cropping

I cropped the final image from the previous exercise to give three different versions:-
Square crop

Letterbox crop

Portrait crop

I still preferred the original image (shown in previous post). The council houses and recreation ground in the foreground are shown more prominently and present a total contrast with the huge cathedral behind. The letterbox framing presents the cathedral more attractively but conceals its rather incongruous surroundings.